One of our favorites for a crowd, this Citrus Rum Punch is perfect for any party or big game; it’s a delicious blend of several fruits, rum, and Luxardo Maraschino Liqueur. Yum!
Although I did make this Citrus Rum Punch just for the Super Bowl and I won’t deny it might wear the colors of my favorite team but it’s funny; I’m not as stressed about the outcome of this game as most rabid fans might be.
Of course I want Peyton (my cat’s namesake even!) and the Broncos to win but I spent 10 wonderful years in North Carolina years ago, my children were born there and my daughter now lives just outside of Charlotte where the other team actually plays.
It’s a hard call for a true Broncos fan. This must be how the Williams family felt for many years; wanting their older daughter Venus to win because she had worked so hard for longer but wanting the same good things for her younger sister Serena. Torn for sure! So I say to Broncos fans and Panther fans alike; this Citrus Rum Punch is for you!
This Citrus Rum Punch really is the perfect punch for this time of year when Florida citrus floods the market. I actually first saw this recipe in an issue of Bon Appetit where it called for blood oranges. Those have not been easy to find this year so I just used pink grapefruit instead for that beautiful color and subbed in regular oranges. I also used bottled grapefruit juice and I’m glad I did.
This was really good and not too sweet but any less sugar and it would have been too little. The grapefruit juice I keep on hand for cocktails contains sweetened juice so if you decide to juice fresh grapefruit you might have to add additional simple syrup.
I decided to add some limes to the mix; just because. As much as I love lemon, I love limes more and I knew the addition of lime juice would only be something good. And it was.
This cocktail for Citrus Rum Punch includes two rums; half is a ‘regular’ dark rum. Although the Bon Appetit recipe specified a high proof rum I didn’t bother to go on that search and used a dark rum I had on hand.
The other rum called for is a Spiced Rum and I used BACARDÍ Oakheart Spiced Rum. This rum is crafted by Maestros de Ron BACARDÍ from heavily charred oak barrels to obtain a unique, smoky flavor before it’s filtered through charcoal and finished by adding a secret blend of spices. The perfect accompaniment for all of the citrus in the punch.
I realized as I finished up with the photography for the Citrus Rum Punch that I hadn’t even tasted it yet. It’s not the first time either but after almost 5 years of doing a cocktail every week you do start to gain confidence from an ingredient list and just know what sounds great and I’ve been lucky…I’ve never had one fail me yet.
Still; once I was done with photos I’ll take a sip and if corrections need to be made I can do them then and revise the recipe accordingly. Tastes too boozy? I might add a bit of club soda to the recipe (and this would be a nice way to stretch this cocktail a bit if you need to).
Needs a bit more sugar? An easy fix with simple syrup. So, I took that first sip and remember hearing myself say, ‘Yum!’ First impressions are the best sometimes!
When I have a success and especially when I have a whole pitcher of a success like I did with this Citrus Rum Punch Cocktail I’ll call a neighbor to come sample the results to see if my take goes beyond me and is enjoyable for them too. Last night it was my buddy Amy and shortly after she showed up her hubs Casey got home and joined us.
Casey is not much of a drinker; as much as anything because his job as a District Wildlife Manager has him on call so often. But I’ll tell you what; he is a great barometer because he’s also a bit of a fussy eater and drinker. When Casey likes it? I know I’ve got a winner!
He tried a sip of Amy’s cocktail and asked for his own. What can I say…this one really is that good! Make a batch for your gang; having a punch to serve is such an easy way to serve cocktails at a party. As a matter of fact I suggest you double it; it’s going to disappear.
Here’s to the Broncos and the Panthers; no matter what else guys, I’m just hoping for a great game…Cheers!
Need More Game Day or Party Food and Cocktails? Here you go…
- Blood Orange Margarita Cocktail
- Pineapple Margarita Cocktail
- Fresh Strawberry Margarita
- The BEST Fresh Margarita
- Orange Creamsicle Cocktail
- Bourbon and Orange Brulee Cocktail
- Classic Cosmopolitan Cocktail
- Lemon Drop Martini
- Watermelon Martini
- French Quarter Cream Cheese Spread
- Baked Brie with Berries and Walnuts
- Artichoke and Roasted Garlic Hummus
- Sweet, Spicy, and Sticky Chicken Wings
- Warm Spinach Dip
- Low Country Shrimp Dip
- Caramelized French Onion Dip
- Artichoke and Parmesan Cheese Dip
- Nacho Momma’s Beef, Bean, and Cheese Dip
PIN IT! ‘Citrus Rum Punch Cocktail’
Citrus Rum Punch Cocktail
- 1 cup dark rum
- 1 cup spiced rum
- 1 cup fresh grapefruit juice strained
- ¾ cup fresh orange juice strained
- ¼ cup fresh lemon juice strained
- ¼ cup fresh lime juice strained
- ⅓ cup Luxardo maraschino liqueur
- ¼ cup simple syrup
- 2 teaspoons Peychaud's bitters
- 1 grapefruit sliced into rounds
- 2 oranges sliced into rounds
- 1 lime sliced into rounds
- For Garnish: Additional slices of citrus your choice:
- Fill a bowl or a small saucepan with water and citrus rounds and freeze (See Notes).
- Combine both rums, grapefruit juice, orange juice, lemon juice, liqueur, simple syrup, and bitters in a pitcher.
- Refrigerate for 2-3 hours or overnight, covered.
- Un-mold ice (briefly dip bottom of container in warm water) and add to punch along with citrus slices in a large bowl. Serve punch in 6-oz. glasses filled with ice. and garnished with citrus sluces.