Smoked Chicken with Beer Cheese Sauce

Smoked Chicken with Beer Cheese Sauce is served over smashed potatoes and finished with a beer/cheese sauce.

Smoked Chicken with Mashed Potatoes and Cheese Sauce

I’ve watched a couple of my friends participate in a unique monthly event called a Recipe Swap. Each month they are given a recipe to start from and their challenge is to ‘swap’ out some of the ingredients to make the end result their own personal and updated take on the original recipe. I joined them and took a roundabout route to this Smoked Chicken with Beer Cheese Sauce for sure.

Want to save this recipe?
Enter your email & I’ll send it to your inbox. Plus, get great new recipes from me every week!
Save Recipe

It sounded fun and creative and I loved seeing their results. That the recipes are from an old cookbook makes it even better; there is an element of simple charm that permeates this book that I really enjoy.

I’ve chatted with Christianna Burwell, she the instigator of this group and a few weeks ago I begged we discussed my joining the group; it seemed so up my ‘I love to change up every recipe I do’ alley.

The inspiration for the recipes that Christianna chooses come from an old cookbook that she found at the Tanque Verde Swap Meet. Titled All-Day Singin’ and Dinner on the Ground, it’s a hymnal and recipe book by Albert E. Brumley and the cookbook is still available for sale on the Brumley Music website. 

The recipes evoke a simpler time and the need for the constant care of a dish; no digital thermometers or Thermidor ovens involved, when paying close care is how you knew a dish was complete. Christianna was inspired to start this project that nods to these recipes from the past and allows us to put our personal spin on them reflective of our own tastes and schedules.

This month the recipe that Christianna chose was for us was Wild Rabbit with Vegetables. Thankful that the whole point of this exercise was to swap out some ingredients and make something new. 

My first order of business was to ‘Welsh’ on using rabbit and use chicken thighs instead. Westley might have had something to do with that (forgive the blurry photo but try taking a photo of a bunny that never sat still!).

While the author of the recipe indicated it was good with tame rabbit, I seriously doubt they meant a rabbit named Westley who was my daughter’s pet, right? Who had a cage near the kitchen and roamed the kitchen and family room at will.

Who anxiously waited for me early in the morning to sit and hand feed him his breakfast of carrots, spinach and other assorted vegetables. No, this was surely not the tame rabbit they meant and I could not bear the thought of eating rabbit any more than I could the thought of, well, let’s just say I have a dog I love too.

Though Westley went to live with a new family after my daughter went back to finish and graduate from college, I can never forget how cute he was.

I wish I could find the photo of him wearing his hand crocheted cap; this little lop eared bunny was just too adorable and he left an indelible impression on my heart and as a result his cousins are safe from my knife forever!

Wikipedia indicates that rabbit meat can be used in most ways chicken meat is used so I did a role reversal and decided to use boneless chicken thighs in lieu of rabbit. In fact, well-known chef Mark Bittman has said that domesticated rabbit tastes like chicken because both are blank palettes upon which any desired flavors can be layered.

I had yet to put together any sort of plan on what to prepare but what kept going through my mind was Welsh Rarebit, also called Welsh Rabbit even though there is nothing rare or rabbit about it. It is another very old recipe that consists of a cheese sauce poured over toast.

And so it began…how could I make a dish with the proscribed ingredients, make a minimal number of substitutions while also including a Welsh Rarebit/Rabbit cheese sauce?

OK, maybe I didn’t have to be this specific but until I put those two columns into an Excel spreadsheet I found it easy to lose track of what I wanted to ‘swap’ and it helped me gain clarity on that task.

I challenged myself to change as few ingredients as possible and yet come up with something entirely unique. If you notice there is not much salt; I had 2 teaspoons total to use for the meat, mashed potatoes and cheese sauce. I ended up using it for the chicken and potatoes. I mean, potatoes without ANY salt? Couldn’t do it!!

Keeping seasoning to a minimum in the potatoes called for me to get creative and why I chose to caramelize the onions in butter and add that to the potatoes…that enhanced their flavor dramatically and when combined with the other components of this dish, no extra seasoning was required.

The chicken thighs came out tasting like pure Heaven. If you can’t smoke your meat and decide to make this recipe I’m sure it will be fine from the grill but I have to tell you…smoke it if you can. The combination of smoked chicken, cheddar cheese with beer and mashed potatoes was, as is popular to say…To. Die. For.

Welsh Wabbit

Fat Tire Beer

I pondered what I had to use; what I could revise and still keep to a dish that represented the ‘spirit’ of the original and went to town. A layered dish of mashed potatoes flavored with caramelized onions, butter and milk; topped with smoked chicken seasoned simply with salt, garlic powder and paprika and finished with a Cheddar Cheese sauce flavored with Fat Tire Ale, a pale ale from the New Belgium Brewing Company.

Was it a prophetic or pathetic reach that I felt this was the perfect brew since my time with Westley was as the result of my daughter going back to Colorado State University in Fort Collins, CO which is the home of New Belgium? No matter, might be both!

My daughter is coming over in a bit to have leftovers. She is bringing a friend. I mentioned smoked chicken and cheddar beer sauce and all of a sudden I have company…ahh…isn’t that what Mom’s are for!

Chicken with Mashed Potatoes and Cheese Sauce

More of our Grilled or Smoked Favorites

Chicken with Mashed Potatoes and Cheese Sauce

Smoked Chicken with Mashed Potatoes and Beer Cheese Sauce

Smoked Chicken is served over smashed potatoes and finished with a beer/cheese sauce.
No ratings yet
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 1 hour 30 minutes
Total Time 1 hour 40 minutes
Course Chicken and Turkey
Cuisine American
Servings 6 Servings
Calories 340 kcal


  • 3 pounds of boneless chicken thighs
  • 2 teaspoons salt divided
  • 1 teaspoon garlic powder
  • teaspoon paprika
  • 5 tablespoon butter divided
  • 2 slices onion diced
  • 2 pounds red baby potatoes
  • 2 tablespoon flour
  • 1 cup sharp cheddar cheese shredded
  • ½ to ¾ cup beer
  • 1 cup half and half or milk, divided
  • Chives for garnish


  • If using boneless chicken thighs, mold them into shape of whole thigh and skewer them to hold together..
  • Mix 1 tsp salt, 1 tsp garlic powder and 1/8 tsp paprika. Season both sides of chicken and either smoke or grill meat. I smoked them at 250 degrees for an hour and they were perfect.
  • Melt 1 Tablespoon of butter in small saucepan and saute chopped onions until just starting to turn brown.
  • In the meantime, boil the potatoes until fork tender, about 15 minutes. Remove from heat, drain off water and return to pan. Do not peel!
  • Mash potatoes coarsely and add caramelized onions, 1/2 cup of milk, 3 Tbsp of butter and 1/2 tsp of salt and mix thoroughly but gently until combined. Keep warm.
  • In saucepan, melt remaining 2 Tbsp of butter. Add flour and cook until butter and flour mixture just starts to turn brown.
  • Add 1/2 cup each of milk and beer to flour mixture and stir til thickened.
  • Add cheese to mixture and stir over low heat until melted and smooth.
  • To serve, put a large spoonful of mashed potatoes on plate, top with a chicken thigh and drizzle each thigh with some of the beer/cheese sauce. Garnish with chopped chives.


Nutrition Facts
Smoked Chicken with Mashed Potatoes and Beer Cheese Sauce
Serving Size
1 Serving
Amount per Serving
% Daily Value*
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Keyword beer, cheddar cheese, chicken, smoked
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Similar Posts


  1. Lol…I don’t know that I couldeat a bunny either. My great grandma called them good eatin’ but she also ate a lot of squirrel, lol. Looks wonderful…and the smoker toy would be Bernie’s dream 🙂

    1. Seems most people feel that way so feeling lucky I didn’t buck the trend…not sure how that would have gone down. The chicken was so good I have no regrets about using it at all. I never had a pet chicken!

    1. Do try it Alison…was one of those dishes i was so glad I made. We had a weekend of cool weather too it was one of those warm comfort food type dishes.

  2. Love all the challenges in the recipe swap group. Love the vintage recipes revitalized. Such fun. Now I just wish I would be organized enough to make one of these deadlines. Great twist Barb! Great recipe!

    1. It was fun Shulie…join in sometime when you can…it definitely stretches us a bit which is part of the fun.

  3. Stunning, stunning, stunning! Am I the only one savage enough to say I would like to try this wonderful recipe with the rabbit as well? lol Awesome smoker and the photos are making my mouth water. I can’t say I would never eat a pet, since I was tricked into eating our pet rabbit one New Years Eve as a child, (My grandmother is very old school hispanic, they always raised what they ate), although I was a bit traumatized, it was not enough keep me away from trying rabbit again, (just never my pets lol) Thanks for sharing this awesome recipe, glad you had fun doing the swap. =]

    1. You savage you! No, really we had others do rabbit and in truth…I might have tried it if I could have found a resource. For rabbit though…could not call it bunny. THAT I could not do, ever.

    1. I think I could become something of a smoker fiend…curing bacon to smoke it next weekend and hoping to get ribs in tomorrow. I want to smoke some different things though…mac and cheese is first on the list.

    1. The sauce may have been made for this dish but it was so good…that beer business was the bomb, it will surely visit other things too. Brats are next I think!

    1. I’m pretty far removed from imagining that I could raise an animal and then use it for dinner. I suppose in some circles that is wrong or weak, but it’s just true. My ex’s family would raise a calf that they knew they would slaughter. I would have had to spirit them away to safety I’m sure!

    1. Thank you Deb…it truly was. I’ve had it for dinner now three nights in a row and I looked forward to it each time!

  4. Westley (Princess Bride anyone?) is adorable, and this sounds delicious! My first pet ever was a bunny I named Jeremiah 🙂

    1. Seems perfect huh…I mean if Bittman says so then chicken it had to be! I am in love with my new smoker. I want to marry it. 🙂

    1. I had a good excuse but without that…rabbit is not something I could have found easily anyhow. I would have had to find a hunter!

  5. Those are some seriously mouth watering photographs and I can so relate to why you chose chicken. Even though I blame my husband for me not cooking rabbit this time, I am sure I would not have the heart to cut and cook a rabbit in my home. And after hearing about the photo of Westley wearing his hand crocheted cap (awwwwww)- the butchering would never happen on my watch! Delicious take on the swap!

    1. Thanks for understanding. If not Westley then I’m sure the bunnies in my backyard would have played a role. Not pets, but sure cute!

    1. I do know Lana…this would be so up your alley too! Let me know if you’re interested; it’s a very creative group but always looking for people who could really get into the challenge with us.

  6. Nice recipes, nice pictures and I love your new smoker! I love rabbit and we used to sell a lot of it 20-30 years ago, only sell a few a month these days (and more boneless and skinless chicken breasts than ever – I don’t get it!) Keep up the good work!

    1. Thanks Mick. Does Tony’s sell rabbit? I didn’t even know where to go if I had wanted to try rabbit! I did opt for boneless thighs and am so glad I did. I admit…I love dark meat and the convenience of having no bone in it was a big plus.

  7. I love this concept of updated old recipes!! Your take on this dish is nothing short of inspired and the results I think speak for themselves!!! This is comfort food on steroids!!

    After seeing the pics of Westley I couldn’t have made the dish with rabbit either!!

    That smoker looks mighty impressive – can’t wait to see what else you “cook up” with it!!

  8. I kinda want to tilt my head back and spoon that cheese sauce in. It looks amazing.

    Funny, Fat Tire just came to MD 2 weeks ago finally. We even have the Chesapeake Commemorative bottle!

    1. I know I just saw a photo of Fat Tire on a site recently. Was that yours? I’m sure that influenced my decision when I went it to buy ONE bottle of beer. It was perfect. Colorado, cute bottle, pale ale. You. 🙂

  9. Scrolling down while reading this lovely post actually gave my heart a start when I saw the picture of Westley! I was totally relieved to read further and see that you swapped out rabbit for chicken! My daughter has had a pet rabbit for seven years (he believes he’s a cat).
    Your recipe looks great and I’m sure it tasted all the more wonderful shared with your daughter and her friend.
    P.S. My Mom used to make rabbit stew and tried to tell me that it was chicken…I always knew it wasn’t and wouldn’t eat it.

    1. So I just changed the title to include the word chicken! I just couldn’t do it and you see why. The girls loved it. Lauren’s friend is teaching herself how to cook; her mom never did it much when they were growing up I guess. I love feeding people but it’s most rewarding when they REALLY enjoy the effort.

    1. Thanks Red. Sorry about the head and the meds. My daughter suffers from allergies but I’ve been pretty lucky. Still, am very empathetic!

    1. I’m sure you know this drill…you decide to try something, thinking it might work and then the end result is so beyond your expectations? That’s what happened here. Blame it on the smoked chicken…elevated the dish completely when joined with the cheddar sauce with beer.

  10. Wow – that first picture alone got my mouth watering. And I am quite jealous of that smoker. What a great contribution to the swap! I had to take my first month off but I can’t wait to get back in the game next month. And now I wanna go see my mom… 🙂

    1. Aw…I’m a sucker for comments that show somebody loves their mom. Thanks for visiting…see you next month I hope at the next swap1

  11. I was nervous to read this post. Rabbit or wabbit, I feel like I’m under the fire. This dish looks amazing and I’m glad to know it’s chicken after all. Whew!

  12. I don’t blame you for a second for swapping out the rabbit. Little bunnies are too cute to eat! But the final dish is gorgeous. Great presentation!

    1. Seems to have been a recurring theme in our group event; something about bunnies right? And thank you…much appreciated comment.

  13. Holy cow…the cheese sauce with chives looks so good! On top of mashed potatoes and chicken…yes, I will be making this soon! Love Fat Tire too…I used to live in Ft. Collins, so New Belgium is dear to me.

    1. Small world isn’t it? I found a recipe for a cheese sauce for Welsh Rarebit that had a much longer list of ingredients but to tell you the truth…this was so good I don’t think anything more was necessary. I mean…it had beer…that meant a lot!

    1. Thanks so much Lindsay, glad to be joined with such a creative group. Chicken was perfect and glad I went that way. This time. 🙂

    1. I’m sort of intrigued now about trying rabbit…but not quite there yet. Just can’t get the image out of my mind of that little guy eating out of my hand.

  14. Adorable bunny photos. Your recipe looks delicious and so relieved that you opted to use chicken thighs instead of rabbit. Love the smoker, you lucky girl. A friend of mine got one of these not long ago and uses the captured smoky drippings to make the best barbeque sauce I have ever eaten. Have fun with that!

    1. Wasn’t he cute? True story. Lauren wanted a house bunny to take back with her for her last year of college so he was a birthday present. Westley, cage, food, toys…everything. We got him a couple of weeks before she would be moving back. They are active at dusk and dawn and that’s when they feed. Soooo…guess who fed him? Well, that would be me cause there was no way she was getting up at dawn to do that, not with mom already up and all! Guess who he favored? Well, that would be the person who fed him…i.e. me. She changed her mind, he was left with me and I tried but he was a lot of work and when I found that a friend’s young daughter was yearning for a house bunny he found a new home and we were all better off. I must say Abbie was happier too…and you know, we want Abbie to be happy, right? 🙂

  15. Love the cheese sauce and the smoked meat, what a classic mix. I wish there was enough room for a smoker on our little balcony, but I’m betting your recipe works great from the grill as well. Great swap!

    1. It does take up some room but until I got it I used a small smoker box from Williams Sonoma. The chips go in the bottom, the food on top, it’s covered and then the box goes on the grill. Was nice but I wanted to do too much to fit inside that 6X12″ box!

  16. Glad to see you used chicken instead of a sweet little fluffy bunny! I just didn’t have the heart to cook one either! I do love Welsh Rarebit and that was a very nice take on the dish, adding some nice elements to a classic! Great job on the swap!

  17. When I saw the photos of the bunny, then visually landed on the plate of ‘meat’ before finishing reading I was REALLY hoping they were completely unrelated! What a clever substitute Barb. Your recipe sounds delicious and undoubtedly all the more fun to make in your new ‘toy’! Sounds like it was a great meeting with Masterbuilt! I used to eat Welsh Rarebit all the time when I visited my Grandparents as a child. I think the sauce was even sold in frozen packets to easily warm up and serve over toast….can’t recall the last time I even thought of it. Where has that dish gone?! Hope you had a nice visit with your daughter and her friends. I’m sure by the looks of this dish, they’ll be back soon!

    1. I recall Welsh Rarebit being the rage oh so many years ago too. It’s a great and simple comfort food but I think I like it better on potatoes than toast so was very glad that something in this challenge moved me in that direction. I do love my new toy…can you hear my ‘Tim the Toolman Taylor’ grunts all the way in Boulder? 🙂

  18. If you had told me what you were serving, I would have flown to Colorado all the way from Serbia:) I don’t blame your daughter at all, as it looks amazing, and I am sure tastes even better.
    We had a rabbit as a pet while growing up, and it would be hard to think of cooking and eating a tame one. But, I try to forget how fluffy and cute they are from time to time, just to enjoy their taste.
    Isn’t the Recipe Swap fun? I am so glad you are with us:)

    1. Well, if I had known that’s what it would take…what if I tell you I have leftovers? It was simply fantastic. Something that came about in this fun swap that I would have never put together otherwise! I’m glad I’m here too…with you and other friends. Cheers Lana!

  19. Barb,

    This looks so good! We have several old (American) cook books from the fifties that the Chef uses from time to time. There is a lot of comfort food within those covers and I think your version looks great. However, it is easy enough to get your hands on rabbit meat here especially now that Autumn is upon us so a bunny stew might be on the menu.
    Hope all is well. The photo of the bunny is great!

    1. Thank you Mona. I’m thinking I might have to do a rabbit challenge…it’s as uncomfortable for many as goat was so a great way to consider stretching ourselves. But for me? Not quite there yet.

  20. That looks particularly conmforting and scrumptious! I would love to be able to smoke my own meat, but when you live in an apartment it is quite difficult…



    1. When I was at the Snowmass Culinary and Arts Festival a few weeks ago, one of the demonstrations showed us how we could create a way to smoke foods in the kitchen. The only thing was, it was outdoors and all I can say is…good thing. Smoke is not for inside! I do have a very small smoker unit that allowed me to smoke on my grill but the results just were not the same, not even close. Wish I could send you some Rosa!

  21. Welsh Wabbit!!! I love it. Barb, thanks so much for being a part of the swap, it’s so fun, and I hope it encourages each of us to take our writing and food-loving to a deeper level. You clearly have, and I enjoyed reading this post.

    1. Thank you Christianna; for the sweet compliment but also for letting me participate. I loved the exercise and just as lovely…was crazy about the end result!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.