Chocolate Puffs from ‘The Hamilton Cookbook’

Chocolate Puffs are an intensely chocolate little treat that will satisfy your sweet tooth and hopefully remind you of the past with the simplicity of ingredients. Not quite a cookie or a meringue, they are an old-fashioned chocolate indulgence!

Chocolate Puffs from 'The Hamilton Cookbook'

My friend Laura Kumin, who blogs at Mother Would Know, recently released her first cookbook, The Hamilton Cookbook: Cooking, Eating, and Entertaining in Hamilton’s World. Laura is a member of the Progressive Eats group I started a few years ago and she had asked the members if we would like to receive a copy of her book and try one of the recipes. I live for trying new recipes…how fun to go back into the past to do it!

Want to save this recipe?
Enter your email & I’ll send it to your inbox. Plus, get great new recipes from me every week!
Save Recipe

Quite honestly the Salamagundy Salad caught my eye and I was dying to make it. Unfortunately to get the true effect of this layered salad I would have had to use the only clear glass bowl I own which is a large trifle bowl and it would have needed salad for 15 to have filled it and looked pretty.

I knew it would mean a lot of waste for me so I commenced searching for a recipe that would work for me now. Now as in I’m making holiday cookies and candies this week for gifts plates for my neighbors. Chocolate Puffs were perfect; call them a cookie or call them a candy; I just call them delicious!

The Hamilton CookbookThe book is a delightful tale on its’ own and the chapters in the book include:

  1. Alexander Hamilton: Who Was He?
  2. Hamilton’s World: 18th Century West Indies and Colonial/Early Federal America
  3. Cooking in Hamilton’s Time
  4. Dining with Alexander Hamilton
  5. Explanation of Recipes
  6. Original & Adapted Recipes

Not just a book of recipes, the author gives us a biography of Alexander Hamilton intertwined with his food experiences. She shares details of his life before he came to America and includes moments heretofore unknown.

Both a family man and a soldier he was so much more and this book makes it evident why there has been such an interest in the man. I mean…there is that little Broadway show too, remember?

You will delight at the research that gives intimate details both of Hamilton’s life and of the details that surround food and food prep, entertaining, and kitchen wares. If you’re intrigued by the musical; then this book can take you a step further into the personal journey of the man. Both a good read and some fun cooking exercises…not every book can promise that!

Beyond simply sharing the history of the times when these recipes would have been current, there is also a photocopy of the original 18th century recipe that inspired Laura. Some translations make for unique measures like you see in this recipe but even more unique is the language; thanks for interpreting this one Laura, not sure I would have had the patience!

‘Take half a pound of double refined fugar, beat and fift it fine; fcrape into it one ounce of chocolate very fine and mix them together; beat up the white of one egg into a very high froth then put in your chocolate and fugar and beat it until it is as ftiff as a pafte; then ftrew fugar on fome writing paper; drop them on about the fize of a fixpence and bake them in a very flow oven; when they are done take them off the paper and put them in plates.”

Not to mention all one sentence…whew; this really was a labor of love!

Chocolate Puffs from 'The Hamilton Cookbook'

Made only from egg white, chocolate and sugar, these Chocolate Puffs from the “Sweets” recipes in The Hamilton Cookbook are naturally dairy-free and gluten-free too. While I don’t personally have to avoid eggs or dairy; I’m hoping friends that do will enjoy these little morsels.

I’ll be honest, I expected them to be lighter and airier due to my familiarity with meringue cookies, also made with egg whites and sugar, but these have a greater concentration of sugar to egg whites resulting in a dough that is thick and almost like a paste.

The result is a crunchier, sweeter cookie/candy with a bit of a sandy texture. A bit sweet on their own so want to know what I accompanied them with? Salted Peanuts! It was as if I had created my own old fashioned version of eating M&M’s with peanuts!

This is a fun read and whether you crave history, love Hamilton the Musical, or just want to try some foods from the past, including these Chocolate Puffs, it’s a book worth having.

PIN IT! ‘Chocolate Puffs from ‘The Hamilton Cookbook’

Chocolate Puffs on a White Serving Plate

Chocolate Puffs from 'The Hamilton Cookbook'

Chocolate Puffs from 'The Hamilton Cookbook'

Creative Culinary
This recipe is reprinted with permissions from The Hamilton Cookbook by Laura Kumin.
No ratings yet
Prep Time 15 minutes
Additional Time 1 hour
Total Time 1 hour 15 minutes
Course Cookies, Brownies and Bars
Servings 2 dozen


  • 1 cup plus 2 Tbsp superfine sugar I use my food processor and pulse for a minute
  • ¼ cup plus 1 and 1/2 Tbsp unsweetened cocoa preferably Dutch process
  • 1 egg white
  • cream of tartar pinch (optional)


  • Preheat the oven to 225° F. Set aside two parchment-lined cookie sheets.In a medium-small bowl, whisk together the sugar and cocoa until they are a uniform color. Set the mixture aside.
  • With a hand beater, stand mixer, or clean whisk, whip the egg white until it is very frothy and beginning to stiffen. (When using a hand or stand mixer to whip egg whites, start at a low speed and slowly raise the speed to medium. Do not use the higher speeds because egg whites whipped that way are less stable.)
  • If desired, add a pinch of cream of tartar to help the egg white froth and stiffen. Once the egg white reaches the soft peak stage, slowly add the sugar/cocoa mixture while continuing to beat the egg white. The result should be a thick paste.
  • Wet your hands slightly and form the batter into small coins about ¾-inches in diameter. Place them on the parchment-lined cookie sheets and bake for 1-1½ hours.
  • Store the cookies in a tightly covered container.


I decided that I had to use a baking tip to get a more decorated cookie. Laura warned me that this dough was stiff and it might be difficult. Listen to Laura. I got a workout for sure; even with what I consider a huge tip. I'm not regretting that I did it, but next time I want to make these little chocolate morsels I'll do it her way!


Nutrition Facts
Chocolate Puffs from 'The Hamilton Cookbook'
Serving Size
1 grams
Amount per Serving
% Daily Value*
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Similar Posts


  1. Chocolate puffs are new to me, especially since Hamilton’s cookbook I started reading recently, it’s been a godsend for me. It keeps my time and nerves organized and makes me more successful

    1. So sorry I didn’t get back to you sooner Judy; I saw your message and figured out what had happened and fixed it…but was out with a client and totally spaced letting you know! Thanks for the heads up!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.